I Visited NYC’s Oldest Irish Tavern — Things That Surprised Me

• Ahead of St. Patrick’s Day, I visited McSorley’s Old Ale House, which was established in 1854.
• I was surprised by the inexpensive prices and the quality of the food.
• I was also surprised by how it made me feel pride as an Irish American. 

I’ve lived in New York City for almost four years, but I have never been to McSorley’s, the oldest Irish pub in the city.

Not only is McSorley’s the most historic Irish tavern in New York, but it’s also often called the oldest Irish tavern in America that’s still in operation. Established in 1854, McSorley’s is celebrating its 170th anniversary this year, and it is certainly the place to go around St. Patrick’s Day. 

Though famous, McSorley’s hasn’t always been on the right side of history. According to The New York Times, women have only been allowed inside the bar since 1970, when two members of the National Organization for Women sued the bar for violating the equal-protection ordinance of the 14th Amendment. There were also no female bartenders until the mid-’90s, according to Bedford + Bowery.

Ahead of St. Patrick’s Day 2023, I wanted to visit the bar given its rich history and connection to my heritage. My grandparents were first-generation Irish immigrants who later moved to England. That fact, in combination with my very Irish name, makes me proud of the close connection to my heritage.

I was surprised by how much I enjoyed my experience at McSorley’s during my visit last year. Here are some things that might surprise you about the oldest Irish bar in the country if you choose to visit yourself.